Damien Harte: Sentence Reduced on Appeal

The Court of Appeal in Belfast has reduced the prison sentence of Phoenix Law client Damien Harte after finding that substantial, unexplained delay in bringing his case to trial had a damaging effect on his mental health. His sentence of 5 years and 3 months has been reduced to 4 years and 9 months.

Sentence Reduced on Appeal

Mr Harte, 52, from Lurgan, Co Armagh, had pleaded guilty to offences committed in 2017 relating to possession of articles which give rise to a reasonable suspicion that they could be of use in terrorism. In October 2025 he received a sentence of 5 years and 3 months.

Phoenix Law, instructed on the appeal against sentence, argued that the trial judge failed to take into account the delay in the case and the detrimental impact of that delay on Mr Harte. The Court of Appeal, comprising the Lady Chief Justice Dame Siobhan Keegan, Lord Justice Colton and Mr Justice McDowell, accepted those submissions and allowed the appeal, reducing the sentence by six months.

Breach of the Right to a Trial Within a Reasonable Time

Mr Harte’s home was first searched in June 2017. There was then an unjustifiable gap of four years between his first police interview and the service of the first page of evidence against him. During that time the file passed between prosecutors while inquiries with US authorities did nothing to progress the investigation.

The prosecution conceded that the delay in this case could not be fully justified. The Court of Appeal found that the hold-up undoubtedly led to a deterioration in Mr Harte’s mental health over a seven-year period, and identified a breach of the legal requirement to a fair trial within a reasonable period of time, as protected by Article 6 of the European Convention on Human Rights.

Delivering the judgment, the Lady Chief Justice said: “This was a case of unexplained delay, and it was substantial.” She added that the court hoped a message would be sent that cases of this nature should be progressed in a much more timely manner.

Comment from Phoenix Law

James Morgan of Phoenix Law, who represents Mr Harte, said:

“We welcome the decision reached by the Court of Appeal today and also welcome the Lady Chief Justice’s comments about sending a message on delay in future cases. It was always our position that this case should have progressed a lot sooner. There was an unjustifiable four-year gap between Mr Harte’s first interview and receiving the first page of evidence against him, and no good reason was given by the PPS for the delay in bringing it to trial. This is a clear breach of Mr Harte’s Article 6 right to a fair trial within a reasonable time.”

Expert Court of Appeal Solicitors in Belfast

Phoenix Law is a Belfast-based firm of criminal defence and human rights solicitors with extensive experience of appeals against conviction and sentence in the Court of Appeal in Northern Ireland, including complex and terrorism-related matters. Where delay, procedural unfairness or a failure to take account of relevant mitigation has affected a sentence, an appeal may result in that sentence being reduced.

If you or a family member wish to discuss a criminal appeal or a sentence that may be manifestly excessive, contact our criminal defence team on 028 9032 8383 or at info@phoenix-law.org.